The Italian banking shake-up is entering a decisive week, with the Banca Monte dei Paschi di Siena shareholders’ meeting set to choose between Lovaglio’s plan and Intesa Sanpaolo’s offer. The outcome concerns the entire FTSE MIB, where banks and insurers now account for nearly half of the index. October has already been an extremely difficult month for the sector, with double-digit declines for many of the stocks involved in the restructuring.
Banking Shake-Up and Its Weight on the FTSE MIB
On October 29, the extraordinary shareholders’ meeting of Monte dei Paschi di Siena (MPS) will vote on the exchange offers for Banco BPM and Banca Generali, which are at the heart of CEO Luigi Lovaglio’s plan. The plan also includes an extraordinary distribution of approximately €4 billion.
However, the banking shake-up is more complex because a countermove is also on the table. This is Intesa Sanpaolo’s exchange-and-takeover offer, which provides 1.6 of its own shares plus €1.25 in cash for each Monte Paschi share. The offer is worth approximately €31.4 billion, but will lapse if the shareholders’ meeting approves Lovaglio’s transactions.
The opposition to the MPS plan, led by Delfin and Caltagirone, already controls more than one-third of the capital. The Fondazione Mps, the historic Siena-based shareholder, has also moved toward accepting Intesa Sanpaolo’s offer. The merger with Mediobanca remains in the background, with Intesa seeking to postpone it until the transaction has been completed. Lovaglio continues to insist that the matter will not be decided before the vote.
Black October for Piazza Affari’s Banks
As the vote approaches, October is exacting a heavy toll on the banking sector, as shown by the performance figures. Banco BPM is down 16.82% since the start of the month, while UniCredit, an interested observer in the banking shake-up, has declined 11.86%. It is followed by Mediobanca at -11.28%, Intesa Sanpaolo at -10.81% and Banca Generali at -10.53%. Only Unipol, down 4.97%, is outperforming the index, while MPS and BPER stand at -8.97% and -8.57%, respectively. Since the beginning of the year, Mediobanca remains positive at +41.02%, followed by Unipol at +22.94%, MPS at +14.52% and BPER at +9.47%. The FTSE MIB future, meanwhile, has limited its monthly decline to -5.48%.
How Much Weight Do Banks and Insurers Carry in the FTSE MIB?
The figures explain why the Siena battle is affecting the whole of Piazza Affari. According to Borsa Italiana statistics as of September 30, banks account for 36.4% of the index’s market capitalization. Adding insurers Generali and Unipol brings the figure to 44.4%, a share that fell to around 43% following October’s declines. Based on the effective weights calculated on the free float, the financial sector accounts for almost half of the index. It is therefore unsurprising that European banks are outperforming US banks while the FTSE MIB is losing more than Wall Street.
Italian Banks and the FTSE MIB: The Rally Has Been Almost Entirely Erased
The comparison between the Italian banking index and the FTSE MIB provides a clear measure of the sector’s condition. The FTSE Italia All-Share Banks and the Amundi FTSE MIB ETF had both reached approximately +20% since the beginning of the year by mid-August. Today, the banking index stands at +1.98% and the FTSE MIB ETF at +4.84%, with October having almost entirely erased the gains built up over eight months. Banks have amplified every move in the broader market, during the March collapse as well as the summer rally and October decline. With financial stocks accounting for nearly half of the index, the outcome on October 29 will inevitably move the entire FTSE MIB.






